
There are all sorts of reactionary articles online condemning the intricate details of the intersectional feminist movement, citing it as sexist, oppressive, incorrect, racist, baseless, etc. This has become especially prominent in the past month, since many people seem to have found Trump’s presidential win to suddenly made it ok to publicly slam the feminist. There’s a horribly regressive side to this coin, but there’s also a positive spin: by removing our censored opinions, we open the table up for more realistic discussion.
One such article from the Washington Post, entitled How To Make Feminism Great Again seems riddled with clickbaity, controversial idealism. This is abundantly clear when the author says: “First of all, it’s time to stop calling the United States a patriarchy. A patriarchy is a system where men hold the power and women do not.”
Let’s get semantical for a moment here, because this seems to address the modern social connotations of the word rather than the reality of it. The definition of a Patriarchy doesn’t say that women do not hold power, it says that women are largely excluded from it. Of course, language isn’t exactly static, so it’s possible this the author of this article is simply using another translation — but let’s accept the word at its less rigid state. Another definition from the OED calls patriarchy “(t)he predominance of men in positions of power and influence in society, with cultural values and norms favouring men.”
America was founded on Patriarchal values, and so, inherently, a great deal of this system persists to this day. This does not mean women inside of a Patriarchal society are without value, it simply means that they are generally, systematically placed on a different, often lower, tier. In many social situations, this may not be the case. In many, it is.
In establishing the USA as a Patriarchy because, for better and for worse, it absolutely, undeniably is, all we need to do is look at the political system, truly the best, most absolute representation of ‘power’ within the country. In succession to the Obama Presidency, the top five members have been men, followed by a disproportionate amount of women. In the prospective Trump presidency, the first woman is even further down the list(number twelve) and currently much less representional(12:2 male female ratio).
While this is a reflection of Patriarchy, it doesn’t necessarily mean that what the system needs is a contrived course correction by firing all of these people and entirely reforming the cabinet equally by a gendered mandate. That style of thinking is obtuse, misdirected, and totally only works when considered transitively with a goal that sidesteps the genuine needs of politics; the people chosen for the cabinet are what the President and his administration consider to the best people for the job. The same could be said about predominately male boards in the corporate sector. This is a reflection of systemized patriarchal conditions, especially when we recognize that these aren’t exactly entry level jobs: that the best people available for the jobs(and by that I mean those socially bred for these conditions and grown into these roles, not a reflection on natural ability) are, by and large straight, white males(not a dirty word, just the reality). This means that these straight, white males have received different societal treatment, different pushes toward different career paths, and have engaged in more relatable interactions with an already white, male, upper echelon of the world.
This isn’t something that we can simply change overnight(and, truthfully, can’t be changed unless people actually want it to be changed), I’m merely offering this as a reality that we need to be aware of. Recognizing that the straight, white male has benefitted from a privileged place in our society does not demonize him. Acknowledging privilege does not mean that a person has to apologize for it.
Let’s not be afraid of language — we can realize that the United States is a Patriarchal society without using that as a reason to cast blame or burn the whole thing down. We can see value in a Patriarchal society, just as we could see value in Matriarchal one.
Of course, the reality of the Patriarchy often shines through in weird, uncomfortable, objectionable ways: Trump’s minister of labour pick, burger baron Andy Puzder, defended his hyper-sexualized television ads in 2015 by simply objectifying: “I like beautiful women eating burgers in bikinis,” he said. “I think it’s very American.”
But, despite what this kind of regressive ideology can suggest when applied against a nationalistic backdrop, things have changed in recent years. There are now more women than men enrolled in post-secondary education. Women dominate different segments of the marketplace than men. Whether it be by socially constructed gendered ideologies or by an inherent difference in the sex, the truth is that men and women embody different things, and these are often considered in two separate political ideologies: men as conservative, women as liberal.
In a lot of ways, we live in a culture that respects women as much as it respects men. In a lot of places and a lot of fields, there’s a wobbling line of equality that prefers different races, sexes or creeds for different things, and so long as those divisions exist there will always be room for a discussion of feminism and equality because the relationships between unrelated things often can’t be relegated to different objective values. Women may be more predisposed to different paths and identities, but we need to realize that these difference are more often constructed and social rather than biological. This comes down to the ‘Nature vs. Nurture’ debate on another level: people are determined by 19-20,000 genes, passed down hereditarily, that are monitored by a single genetic SRY switch. “Turn SRY on, and an animal becomes anatomically and physiologically male. Turn it off, and the animal becomes anatomically and physiologically female.” (The Gene, Siddhartha Mukherjee) A simple switch like this defines ones makeup, and merely monitors the same genes that could potentially have been either gender — we need to recognize that the cultural nurturing of gender has an enormous influence, and is part of a conversation that still has not reached a definitive conclusion.
“Turn outward the woman’s (organs) and double the man’s, and you will find the same,” Galen, the 2nd century philosopher once said. While this is obviously untrue, the fact that such a theory could be offered and accepted as likely suggests a less oppositional contrast between sexes in cultural opinion.
Let’s recognize that a Patriarchal government aligns with a system of power and control. Let’s realize that femininity is, to the average male in American culture, a negative quality. Anecdotally, a coworker once told me that, despite the fact that they’re probably delicious(this has been confirmed as objectively true by the staff of The Wild Now), he has no interest in ever trying a Pumpkin Spice Latte because he isn’t “a fucking white girl.”
In blue collar circles, the reality of men affecting a negative, oppressive attitude toward women is incredible. Even from personal experience, sexism is incredibly alive and thriving today. Another co-worker once commented on an error a female co-worker made, citing the issue being with the company deciding to trust “a woman” with one of the more important jobs.
This plays into another point brought up in the Post article: “In a 2013 poll, Pew asked American mothers about their “ideal” working arrangement. Sixty-one percent said they would prefer to work part-time or not at all.”, citing it as regressive not to credit this as simply personal choice rather than a reflection of an economic system. But in the bottom barrel of the economic system, most of the men that I know would likely feel the same way if it was more socially agreeable to do so. Our culture ingrains gendered values: men as the worker, women as the homemaker. Men as the strong, masculine figure, women as the decorative, empathetic figure. In this economic climate, of course there are a great number of people who would rather not have to work oppressive hours for incredibly low wages; 42.4 percent of all waged earners in America currently make less than what is considered a ‘living wage’, which creates a negative, unrewarding environment.
But the article is smart and sensibly written, closing with the idea that “(i)f (the) voice (of feminism) is calm and judicious rather than hyperbolic and harping, people just might listen.”
The issue with this is that change does not occur because of calmly and judiciously opposing an ideology. Change comes from practically opposing it; it comes from having a voice and using it. Whether or not one believes in the reality of the Feminist movement and what it opposes, it’s audacious to expect those with a voice to use it by this definition, and slapping words with enormously negative connotations like ‘harping’ to an ideology that one simply doesn’t agree is simply trying to compromise the legitimacy of that movement. The responses to Martin Luther King’s own campaigning for Civil Rights, now almost universally agreed upon as an important and genuine thing, were similar to the kinds of attitudes we see against feminism today:




“It would be well if every American Negro compared his position and opportunity with that of his race in other countries. He would find that in none does the Negro have the advantages the United States gives him.” one of the letters reads.
The important movements in history have been the ones that challenge the difficult, preconceived ideals. The moral rectitude inherent to the discussion seems obvious through a retrospective lens, but that wasn’t the reality those people inhabited, just as our own place in the world is defined by its own constructed values and society.
Speaking out in support of women and mocking men for their inability to understand is reactionary and at least partially valid, but let’s remember that there are often cases where the question “what about men” isn’t a joke: “Most backbreaking, lethally dangerous jobs — roofer, logger, roustabout and coal miner, to name a few — are done by men. It is men — especially working-class men — who are disproportionately crushed, mutilated, electrocuted or mangled at work. Activists lament the dearth of women in the Fortune 500, but they fail to mention the Unfortunate 4,500 — the approximate number of men killed on the job every year.” the Post article says.
Patriarchy is not a dirty word — it’s a realization and recognition of the state of things in our world. So long as people are varied and unique, which hopefully they always will be, we are always going to find ways to differentiate ourselves by our sexes, our races, our body types, our interests… what we can’t be is afraid to talk about these things. We can’t shoot down everything that a straight white male says just because of the colloquial response “of course he feels that way, he’s a straight white male”, but we also can’t shoot down the girl who condemns what he’s saying. We all have genuine beliefs and platforms that are worth recognizing. There’s nothing wrong with a beautiful girl in a bikini eating a cheeseburger, but when that’s considered a fundamental piece of the American puzzle by actual members of the government, then there’s an oppressive reality of Patriarchal establishment that truly, undeniably exists. Let’s do our best to all band together and continue the likely never-ending path toward equality.